All-Time Starting Nine for Every MLB Team

More than 19,500 players have played Major League Baseball. These are the best at every position in the history of every team.

All-Time Starting Nine for Every MLB Team

Where would we be without baseball? Well, we've got the ultimate game for you. It’s an all-time tournament. That's right. We’ve picked the best player at every position in the history of every MLB team and ranked the clubs in order.

The ground rules:

Individual performances are based on key statistics and metrics (namely, Wins Above Replacement/162 games), historical significance and team success, in that order.
Each team includes nine players who could play their respective positions. In other words, each has a left fielder, center fielder and right fielder as opposed to three outfielders. To be eligible, a player had to play about two seasons (300 games) at a given position to be in the conversation.
All major leaguers from 1901 to the present were eligible. That includes liars, cheaters, thieves and no-good scumbags. By all means, feel free to cut and paste.
Since the designated hitter position wasn’t around in the pre-expansion days, it’s not included here, we're glad to report.

OK, batter up.

32. San Diego Padres: Mr. Padre and the Choir Boys

Seasons: 52 (1969-present)

Record: 3,747-4,389 (.461)

Playoff appearances: 5

Pennants: 2 (1984, 1998)

World championships: 0

Winningest manager: Bruce Bochy (951-975, .494)

Note: Stats are updated through June 4, 2020. Seasons and slash lines (batting average/on-base percentage/slugging percentage for position players, records/earned-run average for pitchers) are listed with the stated team only. Hall of Famers are noted with asterisks.

San Diego Padres Starting Nine

Catcher: Terry Kennedy (1981-86, .274/.319/.407)

First base: Adrian Gonzalez (2006-10, .288/.374/.514)

Second base: *Roberto Alomar (1988-90, .283/.339/.379)

Shortstop: *Ozzie Smith (1978-81, .231/.295/.278)

Third base: Ken Caminiti (1995-98, .295/.384/.540)

Left field: Gene Richards (1977-83, .291/.357/.387)

Center field: Kevin McReynolds (1983-86, .263/.319/.438)

Right field: *Tony Gwynn (1982-2001, .338/.388/.459)

Pitcher: Jake Peavy (2002-09, 92-68/3.29)

Bottom Line: San Diego Padres

Of the franchises that have been around for the last 50 years, this one is the most bereft of superstar talent. Gene Richards? We were so desperate to find a legit left fielder, the San Diego Chicken was next in line.

The lone exception was Tony Gwynn, who dwarfed Brian Giles, Dave Winfield and everyone else. Also considered: catcher Gene Tenace, left fielder Carmelo Martinez, shortstop Garry Templeton, second basemen Mark Loretta and Alan Wiggins.

One last thought. Gene Richards?!

What People Say About the San Diego Padres

Ozzie Smith fielding — Ozzie Smith, aka "The Wizard of Oz," made tough plays look easy in the field.

"Winfield goes back to the wall, he hits his head on the wall and it rolls off! It’s rolling all the way back to second base. This is a terrible thing for the Padres." —Longtime San Diego Padres broadcaster Jerry Coleman, turning a Dave Winfield outfield misplay into one of the funniest misspoken baseball calls of all time

31. Tampa Bay Devil Rays/Rays: The Young and the Hopeless

Tampa Bay Rays second baseman Ben Zobrist fields a groundball in 2009.

Seasons: 23 (1998-present)

Record: 1,686-1,876 (.473)

Playoff appearances: 5

Pennants: 1 (2008)

World championships: 0

Winningest manager: Joe Maddon (754-705, .517)

Tampa Bay Devil Rays/Rays Starting Nine

Catcher: Toby Hall (2000-06, .262/.298/.382)

First base: Carlos Pena (2007-10, 2012, .230/.360/.483)

Second base: Ben Zobrist (2006-14, .264/.354/.429)

Shortstop: Julio Lugo (2003-06, .287/.350/.421)

Third base: Evan Longoria (2008-17, .270/.341/.483)

Left field: Carl Crawford (2002-10, .296/.337/.444)

Center field: Kevin Kiermeier (2013-present, .249/.306/.416)

Right field: Aubrey Huff (2000-06, .287/.343/.477)

Pitcher: David Price (2008-14, 82-47/3.18)

Bottom Line: Tampa Bay Devil Rays/Rays

Tampa Bay Rays center fielder Kevin Kiermaier leaps at the wall to make a catch in 2019.

Pitcher Scott Kazmir, left fielder Melvin Upton Jr. and catchers Dioner Navarro and Wilson Ramos also got looks here.

So, yeah, the cupboard is pretty much bare. Hard to stock it with such short expiration dates, you know.

Expect this lineup to remain much the same for a while.

What People Say About the Tampa Bay Devil Rays/Rays

David Price pitching — David Price won 82 games in seven seasons with the Rays.

"Tampa Bay, like any other expansion team, toiled and persevered in its infancy—but today, minus the Devil, the Rays have become one of the most exciting teams in baseball." —Author Tucker Elliot, "Tampa Bay Rays IQ: The Ultimate Test of True Fandom," published in 2011

30. Colorado Rockies: The Venus De Milo All-Stars

Larry Walker, right, was the Rockies' first Hall of Famer.

Seasons: 28 (1993-present)

Record: 2,033-2,280 (.471)

Playoff appearances: 5

Pennants: 1 (2007)

World championships: 0

Winningest manager: Clint Hurdle (534-625, .461)

Colorado Rockies Starting Nine

Catcher: Jeff Reed (1996-99, .286/.373/.456)

First base: Todd Helton (1997-13, .316/.414/.539)

Second base: DJ LeMahieu (2011-18, .299/.352/.408)

Shortstop: Troy Tulowitzki (2006-15, .299/.371/.513)

Third base: Nolan Arenado (2013-present, .295/.351/.546)

Left field: Matt Holliday (2004-08, 2018, .319/.387/.550)

Center field: Charlie Blackmon (2011-present, .304/.360/.509)

Right field: *Larry Walker (1995-2004, .334/.426/.618)

Pitcher: Ubaldo Jimenez (2006-11, 56-45/3.66)

Bottom Line: Colorado Rockies

Of the top 10 WAR leaders in Rockies history, nine are position players. Because someone has to pitch the ball, Ubaldo Jimenez was as good a pick as any.

Catcher and left field were jump balls. Jeff Reed beat out Chris Ianetta at one, while Holliday was the choice over Carlos Gonzalez at the other.

We couldn’t overlook that Holliday was the 2007 NLCS Most Valuable Player and hit five homers that postseason. Or that "Big Daddy" scored the run that clinched the only pennant in franchise history, even if he still hasn’t touched home plate.

What People Say About the Colorado Rockies

Charlie Blackmon congratulated by Rockies teammates after a walk-off home run — Charlie Blackmon is a new generation Rockies star.

"Is Coors Field a good park to hit in? Yeah. So are Wrigley Field and Camden Yards. I didn't design Coors Field-I just play there." —Rockies legend Todd Helton

29. Seattle Pilots/Milwaukee Brewers: Under the Hill Gang

Seasons: 52 (1969-present)

Record: 3,913-4,217 (.481)

Playoff appearances: 6

Pennants: 1 (1982)

World championships: 0

Winningest manager: Phil Garner (563-617, .477)

Seattle Pilots/Milwaukee Brewers Starting Nine

Catcher: Jonathan Lucroy (2010-16, .284/.342/.436)

First base: Prince Fielder (2005-11, 1996, .282/.390/.540

Second base: Jim Gantner (1976-92, .274/.319/.351)

Shortstop: *Robin Yount (1974-93, .285/.342/.430)

Third base: *Paul Molitor (1978-92, .303/.367/.444)

Left field: Ryan Braun (2007-present, .298/.360/.533)

Center field: Carlos Gomez (2010-15, .267/.325/.452)

Right field: Sixto Lezcano (1974-80, .275/.354/.452)

Pitcher: Teddy Higuera (1985-1991, 1993-1994, 94-64/3.61)

Bottom Line: Seattle Pilots/Milwaukee Brewers

Robin Yount gets a hit in Game 1 of the 1982 World Series against the St. Louis Cardinals.

As that Hall of Fame philosopher Casey Stengel would say, "Can’t anybody here pitch this game?" The list of candidates was so short, we even considered original Pilot hurler Jim "Ball Four" Bouton for the assignment.

Sixto Lezcano will keep the seat warm for Christian Yelich, who is well on his way. Third baseman Jeff Cirillo, first baseman George Scott and outfielders Geoff Jenkins, Ben Oglivie and Gorman Thomas also were in the hunt.

Fear the beer or bottoms up? You make the call.

What People Say About the Seattle Pilots/Milwaukee Brewers

Milwaukee Brewers' Prince Fielder congratulated by Ryan Braun — Prince Fielder (230 home runs), right, and Ryan Braun (352) combined to hit 582 jacks as Brewers.

"When they talk to me about being the best right fielder, that's one of those things where I say maybe I am, maybe I'm not. If the sportswriters want to say I'm the best, that's their job. I'll keep my mind on the game, not on the letters they put in the paper." — Milwaukee Brewers right fielder Sixto Lezcano in May 1979. Lezcano was known for his strong throwing arm and later that same year won an American League Gold Glove Award, the first Gold Glove in franchise history by any Milwaukee Brewers outfielder.

28. Kansas City Royals: The Little Blue Machine

Kansas City Royals second sacker Frank White in 1977.

Seasons: 52 (1969-present)

Record: 3,901-4,222 (.480)

Playoff appearances: 9

Pennants: 4 (1980, 1985, 2014, 2015)

World championships: 2 (1985, 2015)

Winningest manager: Ned Yost (746-839, .471)

Kansas City Royals Starting Nine

Catcher: Salvador Perez (2011-present, .266/.297/.442)

First base: John Mayberry (1972-77, 1996, .261/.374/.439)

Second base: Frank White (1973-90, .255/.293/.383)

Shortstop: Freddie Patek (1971-79 .241/.309/.321)

Third base: *George Brett (1973-93, .305/.369/.487)

Left field: Willie Wilson (1976-90, .289/.329/.382)

Center field: Lorenzo Cain (2011-17, .289/.342/.421)

Right field: Danny Tartabull (1987-91, .290/.376/.518)

Pitcher: Bret Saberhagen (1984-91, 110-78/3.21)

Bottom Line: Kansas City Royals

The closest race was between Lorenzo Cain, Willie Wilson and Alex Gordon for two outfield spots.

Gordon provided better balance between the 1985 and 2015 World Series champs, but his WAR numbers didn’t quite measure up to the others.

We also chose Freddie Patek over Alcides Escobar because of better defense and stolen base numbers. Oh, and we're partial to anyone nicknamed "The Flea."

What People Say About the Kansas City Royals

Salvador Perez celebrates after scoring a run — Salvador Perez has become one of the game's best catchers since making his MLB debut in 2011 and is building a case for Cooperstown.

"Losing is for losers." —Former Kansas City Royals owner David Glass after winning the 2015 ALDS against the Houston Astros. The Royals went to win the World Series that postseason after years of losing during Glass' tenure, the result of mismanagement and frugality.

27. Arizona Diamondbacks: Dry Heat

Randy Johnson won four straight National League Cy Youngs (199-2002) while pitching for the Diamondbacks.

Seasons: 23 (1998-present)

Record: 1,763-1,801 (.495)

Playoff appearances: 6

Pennants: 1 (2001)

World championships: 1 (2001)

Winningest manager: Kirk Gibson (353-375, .485)

Arizona Diamondbacks Starting Nine

Catcher: Miguel Montero (2006-14, .264/.342/.421)

First base: Paul Goldschmidt (2011-18, .299/.398/.525)

Second base: Jay Bell (1998-2002, .263/.355/.458)

Shortstop: Stephen Drew (2006-12, .266/.328/.436)

Third base: Matt Williams (1998-2003, .278/.327/.471 )

Left field: Luis Gonzalez (1999-2006, .298/.391/.529)

Center field: Steve Finley (1999-2004, .278/.351/.500 )

Right field: Justin Upton (2007-12, .289/.369/.529)

Pitcher: *Randy Johnson (1999-2004, 2007-08, 118-62/2.83)

Bottom Line: Arizona Diamondbacks

For a team that has been around for only two full decades, these Snakes more than hold their own.

In a perfect world, 2001 World Series co-Most Valuable Players Johnson and Curt Schilling would share the mound spot.

In the other close call, Steve Finley beat out A.J. Pollock on the strength of his stellar 2001 postseason.

What People Say About the Arizona Dimaondbacks

Paul Goldschmidt congratulated by Ryan Roberts after homer — Paul Goldschmidt, right, hit 209 home runs with the Diamondbacks.

"I had a long conversation with Steve Carlton. He told me that on the days he pitched, he felt it was his responsibility to make everyone around him better, to lift his teammates. That's what I try to do." —Hall of Fame southpaw Randy Johnson

26. Chicago White Sox: The Oh, What Might Have Beens

Ed Walsh, in 1908, was an all-time great pitcher with the Chicago White Sox.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 9,283-9,215 (.502)

Playoff appearances: 9

Pennants: 6 (1901, 1906, 197, 1919, 1959, 2005)

World championships: 3 (1906, 1917, 2005)

Winningest manager: Jimmy Dykes (899-940, .489)

Chicago White Sox Starting Nine

Catcher: *Carlton Fisk (1981-93, .257/.329/.438)

First base: *Frank Thomas (1990-2005, .307/.427/.568)

Second base: *Eddie Collins (1915-26, .331/.426/.424)

Shortstop: *Luke Appling (1930-43, 1945-50, .310/.399/.398)

Third base: Robin Ventura (1989-98, .274/.365/.440)

Left field: Joe Jackson (1915-20, .340/.407/.499)

Center field: Chet Lemon (1975-81, .288/.363/.451)

Right field: Magglio Ordonez (1997-2004, .307/.364/.525)

Pitcher: *Ed Walsh (1904-16, 195-125/1.81)

Bottom Line: Chicago White Sox

There was a time when this franchise had the best talent in all of baseball. Then came the Black Sox scandal to destroy it. Nearly 100 years later, it startles the senses to think of just how little elite talent has played on the South Side since then.

Eddie Collins, Carlton Fisk and Joe Jackson had their best days elsewhere, which leaves Frank Thomas as the lone homegrown Hall of Famer in the post-expansion era.

What about Harold Baines, the most recent inductee, you ask? We've got him somewhere between Magglio Ordonez and "Jungle" Jim Rivera in right field.

What People Say About the Chicago White Sox

Luke Appling following through — Hall of Famer Luke Appling in 1940.

"(Shoeless Joe) Jackson's fall from grace is one of the real tragedies of baseball. I always thought he was more sinned against than sinning." —Hall of Famer Connie Mack

25. Houston Colt .45s/Astros: Dewey, Cheatem and Howe

Cesar Cedeno, stealing home against the Cubs in 1977, made a lot of plays with the Astros.

Seasons: 59 (1962-present)

Record: 4,601-4,666 (.496)

Playoff appearances: 13

Pennants: 3 (2005, 2017, 2019)

World championships: 1 (2017)

Winningest manager: Bill Virdon (544-522, .510)

Houston Colt .45s/Astros Starting Nine

Catcher: Jason Castro (2010, 2012-16, .232/.309/.390)

First base: *Jeff Bagwell (1991-2005, 1996, .297/.408/.540)

Second base: *Craig Biggio (1988-2007, .281/.363/.433)

Shortstop: Carlos Correa (2015-present, .277/.356/.489)

Third base: Alex Bregman (2016-present, .286/.384/.527)

Left field: Lance Berkman (1999-2010, .296/.410/.549)

Center field: Cesar Cedeno (1970-81, .289/.351/.454)

Right field: Jim Wynn (1963-73, .255/.362/.445)

Pitcher: Roy Oswalt (2001-10, 143-82/3.24)

Bottom Line: Houston Colt .45s-Astros

Houston Astros third baseman Alex Bregman makes a play in 2019.

There are so a lot of steroid addicts and sign stealers here, so we’ve put on rubber gloves to write this. (Sorry, people, but since character is not part of the criteria, we have no choice.)

Jim Wynn was primarily a center fielder, but he played enough in right field to qualify there. Well, until Cheatin' George Springer moves past him, anyway.

Now excuse us. We have to take a shower.

What People Say About the Houston Colt .45s/Astros

Carlos Correa celebrates after walk-off home run — Carlos Correa celebrates after a walk-off home run against the New York Yankees in the 2019 ALCS.

"When you analyze the games, we won fair and square. We earned that championship." —Astros shortstop Carlos Correa on the cheating controversy around their 2017 World Series title

24. California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels: Trout, Salmon and the Angelfish

Bobby Grich, Dan Ford — California Angels Bobby Grich, left, and Dan Ford celebrate a playoff with a fan in 1979.

Seasons: 60 (1961-present)

Record: 4,709-4,719 (.499)

Playoff appearances: 10

Pennants: 1 (2002)

World championships: 1 (2002)

Winningest manager: Mike Scioscia (1,650-1,428, .536)

California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels Starting Nine

Catcher: Mike Napoli (2006-10, .251/.346/.485)

First base: Wally Joyner (1986-91, 2001, .286/.350/.450)

Second base: Bobby Grich (1977-86, .269/.370/.436)

Shortstop: Jim Fregosi (1961-71, .268/.340/.403)

Third base: Troy Glaus (1998-2004, .253/.357/.497)

Left field: Garret Anderson (1994-2008, .296/.327/.469)

Center field: Mike Trout (2011-present, .305/.419/.581)

Right field: Tim Salmon (1992-2004, 2006, .282/.385/.498)

Pitcher: *Nolan Ryan (1972-79, 138-212/3.07)

Bottom Line: California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels

Mike Trout celebrates after hitting a home run in 2015.

Yes, we have no Frank Tanana. We do have Nolan Ryan, whose two 20-win seasons came in a Halos uni.

Bob Boone was a four-time Gold Glover in the twilight of his career, but Mike Napoli packed more punch in his prime. If someone prefers Brian Downing in left field, we won’t kick and scream about. We chose Garret Anderson, the all-time club leader in hits, total bases, RBI and runs scored.

Our heartfelt sympathy goes out to Darin Erstad, who played center field with the wrong team.

What People Say About the California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels

Nolan Ryan throwing pitch — Nolan Ryan won 138 games with the Angels.

"In the movies, I never lost a fight. In baseball, I hardly ever won one." —Former Los Angeles/California Angels owner Gene Autry, who owned the team from 1961 to 1997

23. Florida/Miami Marlins: The Heartbreakers

Gary Sheffield makes a diving catch in Game 7 of the 1997 World Series against the Cleveland Indians.

Seasons: 28 (1993-present)

Record: 1,990-2,314 (.462)

Playoff appearances: 2

Pennants: 2 (1997, 2003)

World championships: 2 (1997, 2003)

Winningest manager: Jack McKeon (281-257, .522)

Florida/Miami Marlins Starting Nine

Catcher: Charles Johnson (1994-98, 2001-02, .241/.324/.418)

First base: Jeff Conine (1993-07, 2003-05, .290/.358/.455)

Second base: Dee Gordon (2015-17, .309/.340/.384)

Shortstop: Hanley Ramirez (2006-12, .300/.374/.499)

Third base: Miguel Cabrera (2003-07, .313/.388/.542)

Left field: Giancarlo Stanton (2010-17, .268/.360/.554)

Center field: Marcell Ozuna (2013-17, .277/.329/.457)

Right field: Gary Sheffield (1993-98, .288/.426/.543)

Pitcher: Josh Johnson (2005-12, 56-37/3.15)

Bottom Line: Florida/Miami Marlins

Giancarlo Stanton hits a home run in 2012.

Can you imagine if two World Series teams weren’t prematurely dismantled and some of these guys had stayed in South Beach a bit longer?

Dee Gordon was around for a cup of decaf, but it was enough for the one-time batting champ to edge out Dan Uggla at second base. Cliff Floyd and Christian Yelich were eligible in left field, where Giancarlo Stanton rocked the most homers and RBI in club history.

Pitcher Jose Fernandez was well on his way to be here before he checked out early.

What People Say About the Florida/Miami Marlins

Florida Marlins' third baseman Miguel Cabrera smiling — Miguel Cabrera made his MLB debut with the Marlins in 2003.

"I guess every little boy imagines this might happen at one time. It's a total fantasy for me. I was a little concerned. We haven't given up all year -- tonight wasn't the time to give up. When we walked into the clubhouse tonight, we knew we were going to be world champions." —Former Marlins manager Jim Leyland on winning the 1997 World Series

22. Washington Senators/Texas Rangers: The Power Rangers

Frank Howard and Senators — Washington Senators players Frank Howard, left, and Brant Alyea shoot the breeze with manager Ted Williams in 1969.

Seasons: 60 (1961-present)

Record: 4,500-4,912 (.478)

Playoff appearances: 8

Pennants: 2 (2010, 2011)

World championships: 0

Winningest manager: Ron Washington (664-611, .521)

Washington Senators/Texas Rangers Starting Nine

Catcher: *Ivan Rodriguez (1991-2002, 2009, .304/.341/.488)

First base: Rafael Palmeiro (1989-93, 1999-2003, .290/.378/.519)

Second base: Ian Kinsler (2006-13, .273/.349/.454)

Shortstop: Alex Rodriguez (2001-03, .305/.395/.615)

Third base: Buddy Bell (1979-85, 1989, .293/.351/.431)

Left field: Frank Howard (1965-72, .277/.367/.503)

Center field: Josh Hamilton (2008-12, 2015, .302/.359/.542)

Right field: Juan Gonzalez (1989-99, 2002-03, .293/.342/.565)

Pitcher: *Fergie Jenkins (1974-75, 1978-81, 93-72/3.56)

Bottom Line: Washington Senators/Texas Rangers

Iván Rodriguez — Texas Rangers catcher Ivan Rodriguez was a first-ballot Hall of Famer.

OK, Junior, how many druggies do you count here? We’ve got six at the least. That’s a half-dozen more than the number of Cy Young Award winners in club history.

We chose Fergie Jenkins over all-time franchise wins leader Charlie Hough and Kevin Rogers, in no small part because of his fabulous 1974 season, when he won 25 games and pitched 328 1/3 innings.

Also in the discussion were second baseman Julio Franco and right fielder Ruben Sierra.

What People Say About the Washington Senators/Texas Rangers

Josh Hamilton celebrating after solo home run — Josh Hamilton played 697 games with the Rangers.

"I guarantee you, the Rangers will not win this year. If the players there don’t like it, I’m sorry. Tell them I’m sorry." —Former Ranger Juan Gonzalez in 2000

21. Seattle Mariners: The Kid and His Playmates

Ken Griffey Jr. after hitting a home run in 1989.

Seasons: 44 (1977-present)

Record: 3,219-3,622 (.471)

Playoff appearances: 4

Pennants: 0

World championships: 0

Winningest Manager: Lou Piniella (840-711, .542)

Seattle Mariners Starting Nine

Catcher: Dan Wilson (1994-2005, .262/.309/.384)

First base: Alvin Davis (1984-91, .280/.380/.450)

Second base: Bret Boone (1992-93, 2001-05, .277/.336/.478)

Shortstop: Alex Rodriguez (1994-2000, .309/.374/.561)

Third base: *Edgar Martinez (1987-2004, .312/.418/.515)

Left field: Raul Ibanez (1996-2000, 2004-08, 2013, .279/.341/.466)

Center field: *Ken Griffey Jr. (1989-99, 2009-10, .292/.374/.553)

Right field: Ichiro Suzuki (2001-12, 2018-19, .321/.365/.416)

Pitcher: *Randy Johnson (1989-98, 130-74/3.42)

Bottom Line: Seattle Mariners

Ichiro Suzuki had 3,089 hits in his career.

Even though this franchise had a comparatively late start, it can put a competitive team on the field.

Alvin Davis was the pick over John Olerud because of that cool trident "M" on his uniform. Check that. We also chose him because he put up solid offensive numbers with little around him.

Bret Boone beat out Robinson Cano at second base despite slightly lesser metrics. Whereas Cano never took part in a postseason game here, Boone was an integral part of the 2001 team that won a record 116 games. That plus two monster seasons and three Gold Glove Awards put him over the top.

What People Say About the Seatlle Mariners

Seattle Mariners shortstop Alex Rodriguez leaps — Alex Rodriguez was the first pick in the 1993 MLB draft.

"I'm damn proud to be a Seattle Mariner." —Ken Grifey Jr.

20. New York Highlanders/Yankees 3.0: And the Next Best Team Money Can Buy

New York Yankees second baseman Gil McDougald grabs a high throw in 1958.

Seasons: 118 (1903-present)

Record: 10,378-7,840 (.570)

Playoff appearances: 55

Pennants: 40 (1921, 1922, 1923, 1926, 1927, 1928, 1932, 1936, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1941, 1942, 1943, 1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1955, 1956, 1957, 1958, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1976, 1977, 1978, 1981, 1996, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2009)

World championships: 27 (1923, 1927, 1928, 1932, 1936, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1941, 1943, 1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1956, 1958, 1961, 1962, 1977, 1978, 1996, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2009)

Third-winningest manager: *Casey Stengel (1,149-696, .623)

New York Highlanders/Yankees 3.0 Starting Nine

Catcher: Jorge Posada (1995-2011, .273/.374/.474)

First base: Bill Skowron (1954-62, .294/.346/.496)

Second base: Robinson Cano (2005-13, .309/.355/.504)

Shortstop: Roger Pekinpaugh (1913-21, .259/.336/.335)

Third base: Gil McDougald (1951-60, .276/.356/.410)

Left field: Brett Gardner (2008-present, .260/.342/.401)

Center field: *Earl Combs (1924-35, .325/.397/.462)

Right field: Roger Maris (1960-66, .265/.356/.515)

Pitcher: *Mariano Rivera (2005-16, 82-60/2.21)

Bottom Line: New York Highlanders/Yankees 3.0

Jorge Posada rounds the bases after hitting a home run during a playoff game in 2009.

Didn’t think the Bronx Bombers would have only one team here, did you? Three Hall of Famer players made their C team, and Robinson Cano could become a fourth eventually.

What’s more, that doesn’t include Reggie Jackson, Mr. October himself. Roger Pepkinpaugh was a somewhat reluctant pick, but we couldn’t dismiss his one American League Most Valuable Award and Gold Glove-caliber defense.

Some would argue that closers don’t belong here. As the greatest ever, Mariano Rivera was given the benefit of the doubt. But if you insist on a starter, Ron Guidry (170-91, 3.29) would be a suitable replacement.

What People Say About the New York Highlanders/Yankees 3.0

Mariano Rivera celebrates — The Yankees won the World Series in 1999.

"I don't just think regular season. I think playoffs, World Series. That's how I think." —Mariano Rivera

19. Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals: The Habs and the Haves

Gary Carter played 1,503 games with the Expos over 12 seasons.

Seasons: 52 (1969-present)

Record: 3,977-4,149 (.489)

Playoff appearances: 6

Pennants: 1 (2019)

World championships: 1 (2019)

Winningest manager: Felipe Alou (691-717, .491)

Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals Starting Nine

Catcher: *Gary Carter (1974-84, 1992, .269/.342/.454)

First base: Ryan Zimmerman (2005-present, .279/.343/.475)

Second base: Jose Vidro (1997-2006, .301/.363/.459)

Shortstop: Trea Turner (2015-present, .291/.348/.467)

Third base: Anthony Rendon (2013-present, .290/.369/.490)

Left field: *Tim Raines (1979-90, .301/.391/.437)

Center field: *Andre Dawson (1976-86, .280/.326/.476)

Right field: *Vladimir Guerrero (1996-2003, .323/.390/.588)

Pitcher: Max Scherzer (2015-present, 79-39, 2.74)

Bottom Line: Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals

Washington Nationals third baseman Ryan Zimmerman made his major league debut in 2005.

Funny what a World Series can do for a franchise, isn’t it? No fewer than four members of the defending champs are on the list.

Les Ressortissants (Nationals) have been blessed in right field, where Bryce Harper and Hall of Famer Larry Walker (former Expo) are in the conversation of best in club history.

Now let’s hear it for Tim Wallach, Montreal's five-time All-Star third baseman.

What People Say About the Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals

Washington Nationals' Trea Turner slides home — Trea Turner scored 444 runs over 637 games with the Nationals.

"Gary Carter was the Montreal Expos. From the moment he first arrived as a September call-up in 1974 and, with a bang, hit his first major league home run off Steve Carlton, there was little doubt he was going to be the Expos' first homegrown franchise player. He didn't just play the part. He looked it. Square-jawed. Clean-cut. Infectious enthusiasm, later derided by some as false hustle. And a smile that could light up Jarry Park. Even from right field." —Sportswriter Mitch Melnick in The New York Times in 2012 after Gary Carter's death

18. Toronto Blue Jays: Team of the Past

Toronto Blue Jay shortstop Tony Fernandez leaps to complete a double play against the Oakland A's in 1989.

Seasons: 44 (1977-present)

Record: 3,383-3,458 (.495)

Playoff appearances: 7

Pennants: 2 (1992, 1993)

World championships: 2 (1992, 1993)

Winningest manager: Cito Gaston (894-837, .516)

Toronto Blue Jays Starting Nine

Catcher: Ernie Whitt (1977-89, .253/.327/.420)

First base: Carlos Delgado (1993-2004, .282/.392/.556)

Second base: *Roberto Alomar (1991-95, .307/.382/.451)

Shortstop: Tony Fernandez (1980-1990, 1993, 1998-99, .297/.353/.412)

Third base: Josh Donaldson (2015-18, .281/.383/.548)

Left field: George Bell (1981, 1983-90, .286/.325/.486)

Center field: Devon White (1991-95, .270/.327/.432)

Right field: Jose Bautista (2008-17, .253/.372/.506)

Pitcher: *Roy Halladay (1998-2009, 1969-84, 148-76, 3.43)

Bottom Line: Toronto Blue Jays

Jose Bautista catches a fly ball in 2010.

Wouldn’t you love to see the Expos/Nats and Blue Jays duke it out in an all-time Canada World Series? Blue Jays in seven.

While Fred McGriff had greater longevity at first base, Carlos Delgado delgotit as the all-time franchise leader in home runs and slugging percentage leader.

The underrated Devon White beat out Lloyd Moseby and Vernon Wells in center field, where he was at his best north of the border.

What People Say About the Toronto Blue Jays

Josh Donaldson hitting — Josh Donaldson hit 116 home runs with the Blue Jays.

"I don’t mind if the guys laugh after we lose. They’ve got to get themselves ready for the next day. The same when we win. Enjoy it, but you can’t take it with you. You’ve got to start again tomorrow." —Former Blue Jays manager Cito Gaston, in 1989, on his even-keeled approach to baseball and life

17. Philadelphia Phillies: The Phlighty Phils

Philadelphia Phillies center fielder Richie Ashburn slides back to first during a spring training game in 1952.

Seasons: 138 (1883-present)

Record: 9,825-11,000 (.472)

Playoff Appearances: 14

Pennants: 7 (1915, 1950, 1980, 1983, 1993, 2008, 2009)

World Championships: 2 (1980, 2008)

Winningest Manager: Charlie Manuel (780-636, .551)

Philadelphia Phillies Starting Nine

Catcher: Carlos Ruiz (2006-16, .266/.352/.393)

First base: Dick Allen (1963-78, .290/.371/.530)

Second base: Chase Utley (2003-15, .282/.366/.481)

Shortstop: Jimmy Rollins (2000-14, .267/.327/.424)

Third base: *Mike Schmidt (1972-89, .267/.380/.527)

Left field: Sherry Magee (1900-14, .299/.371/.447)

Center field: *Richie Ashburn (1948-59, .311/.394/.388)

Right field: Bobby Abreu (1998-2006, .303/.416/.513)

Pitcher: *Pete Alexander (1911-17, 1930, 190-91/2.18)

Bottom Line: Philadelphia Phillies

Philadelphia Phillies third baseman Mike Schmidt hit 548 career home runs.

This franchise has had a major market to itself for the last six-plus decades, but except for the pitcher position, one might expect a bit more here.

Some would argue that Robin Roberts is the best hurler in club history. Others would say Steve Carlton. C’mon, stop it, people. The correct answer is Pete Alexander, who averaged 27 wins and 10 shutouts over seven seasons in the Dead Ball Era.

The bigger question is, who gives the signs? We chose Carlos Ruiz over slugger Darren Daulton because of his better defense and postseason resume, but just barely.

What People Say About the Philadelphia Phillies

Chase Utley curtain call — Chase Utley was a six-time All-Star.

"Philadelphia is the only city, where you can experience the thrill of victory and the agony of reading about it the next day." —Mike Schmidt

16. New York Mets: The Kinda, Sorta Amazin’s

Tom Seaver won 198 of his 311 games with the Mets.

Seasons: 59 (1962-present)

Record: 4,448-4,808 (.481)

Playoff appearances: 9

Pennants: 5 (1969, 1973, 1986, 2000, 2015)

World championships: 2 (1969, 1986)

Winningest manager: Davey Johnson (595-417, .588)

New York Mets Starting Nine

Catcher: *Mike Piazza (1998-05, .296/.373/.542)

First base: Keith Hernandez (1983-89, .297/.387/.429)

Second base: Edgardo Alfonzo (1995-2002, .292/.367/.445)

Shortstop: Jose Reyes (2003-11, 2016-18, .282/.334/.433)

Third base: David Wright (2004-16, 2018, .296/.376/.491)

Left field: Cleon Jones (1963, 1965-75, .281/.340/.406)

Center field: Carlos Beltran (2005-11, .280/.369/.500)

Right field: Darryl Strawberry (1983-90, .263/.359/.520)

Pitcher: *Tom Seaver (1967-77, 1983, 198-124/2.57)

Bottom Line: New York Mets

Mike Piazza was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2016.

The top eight WAR leaders in team history are represented here.

Cleon Jones was the party crasher even if he barely got in the door. Kevin McReynolds had slightly better metrics, but Jones owned a World Series ring. Bonus point: He caught the final out of the 1969 World Series.

Could Jacob deGrom overtake Seaver at some point? The two-time Cy Young Award-winner already ranks No. 4 in WAR in club history, but at 31, he’ll probably run out of time.

What People Say About the New York Mets

New York Mets celebration — The Mets have had their ups and downs.

"God is living in New York, and he's a Mets fan." —Tom Seaver

15. Chicago Orphans/Cubs: The Hope Peddlers

Gabby Hartnett played 1,926 games with the Cubs over 19 seasons.

Seasons: 145 (1876-present)

Record: 10,982-10,404 (.514)

Playoff appearances: 20

Pennants: 17 (1876, 1880, 1881, 1882, 1885, 1886, 1906, 1907, 1908, 1910, 1918, 1929, 1932, 1935, 1938, 1945, 2016)

World championships: 3 (1907, 1908, 2016)

Winningest manager: Charlie Grimm (946-782, .547)

Chicago Orphans/Cubs Starting Nine

Catcher: *Gabby Harnett (1922-40, .297/.370/.490)

First base: *Frank Chance (1898-1912, .297/.394/.395)

Second base: *Ryne Sandberg (1982-95, 1996-97, .285/.344/.452)

Shortstop: *Ernie Banks (1953-1971, .274/.330/.500)

Third base: Kris Bryant (2015-present, .284/.385/.516)

Left field: *Billy Williams (1959-74, .296/.364/.503)

Center field: *Hack Wilson (1926-31, .322/.412/.590)

Right field: Sammy Sosa (1992-2004, .284/.358/.569)

Pitcher: *Mordecai Brown (1904-12, 1916, 188-86/1.80)

Bottom Line: Chicago Orphans/Cubs

Ernie Banks played all 2,528 games of his MLB career with the Cubs and hit 512 home runs.

Where’s Ron Santo?! Please let me explain. Whereas there are two different Santos at the plate — the Wrigley Field version and the road version — Kris Bryant doesn’t play favorites. Moreover, he already owns one more Most Valuable Award and World Series ring in his rather brief career. That trumps five Gold Glove Awards.

The tougher pick was between Mordecai Brown and Fergie Jenkins on the mound. "Three Fingers" got the nod on the basis of his 3-0 World Series record with consecutive championship teams.

Meanwhile, steroids critics who don't want to see Sammy Sosa will be comforted to know that Hall of Famer Kiki Cuyler is available in right field.

What People Say About the Chicago Orphans/Cubs

Sammy Sosa celebrates in locker room — Sammy Sosa hit 609 home runs in his career.

"He never complained about his team's bad luck or bad talent, never stopped playing the game with joy, never stopped giving his all, never lost his proud demeanor, and never acted like anything but a winner. He was a symbol of the Cub fan's undiminishing resilience. If he could be happy to come to the park each afternoon, then so could we." —Actor Joe Mantegna on Ernie Banks

14. Milwaukee Brewers/St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles: The Dream Weaver Train

Baltimore Orioles center fielder Paul Blair after hitting a home run against the Oakland A's in a 1974 playoff game.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 8,768-9,728 (.474)

Playoff appearances: 14

Pennants: 7 (1944, 1966, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1979, 1983)

World championships: 3 (1966, 1970, 1983)

Winningest manager: *Earl Weaver (1,480-1,060, .583)

Milwaukee Brewers/St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles Starting Nine

Catcher: Matt Wieters (2009-16, .256/.318/.421)

First base: *Eddie Murray (1978-88, 1996, .294/.370/.498)

Second base: Bobby Grich (1970-76, .262/.372/.405)

Shortstop: *Cal Ripken Jr. (1981-2001, .276/.340/.447)

Third base: *Brooks Robinson (1955-77, .267/.322/.401)

Left field: Ken Williams (1918-27, .326/.403/.558)

Center field: Paul Blair (1964-76, .254/.306/.388)

Right field: *Frank Robinson (1966-71, .300/.401/.543)

Pitcher: *Jim Palmer (1965-67, 1969-84, 268-152/2.86)

Bottom Line: Milwaukee Brewers/St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles

Cal Ripken Jr. — Cal Ripken was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2007.

The majority of mid-market franchises are best seen in the rearview mirrors, but this one is no exception.

Four of the picks (Paul Blair, Jim Palmer and both Robbys, Frank and Brooks) were cornerstones of the Earl Weaver-managed teams of decades ago. And Eddie Murray and Cal Ripken were the cornerstones of the championship team that would come a decade later. Murray beat out Hall of Famer George Sisler, who twice hit .400 with mostly bad Browns teams.

While Rick Dempsey didn’t swing a big enough bat to claim the catcher spot, his Babe Ruth impersonation still ranks among the best ever.

What People Say About the Milwaukee Brewers/St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles

Matt Wieters gets congratulated by teammates — Matt Wieters, right, was drafted by the Baltimore Orioles in the first round (fifth pick) of the 2007 MLB draft.

"Brooks (Robinson) never asked anyone to name a candy bar after him. In Baltimore, people named their children after him." —Former Associated Press sportswriter Gordon Beard, who was an expert on Baltimorese

13. Boston Beaneaters-Doves-Rustlers-Bees-Braves/Milwaukee Braves/Atlanta Braves: Milwaukee’s Finest

Eddie Mathews had 2,315 career hits, including 512 home runs.

Seasons: 145 (1876-present)

Record: 10,697-10,659 (.501)

Playoff appearances: 25

Pennants: 17 (1877, 1878, 1883, 1891, 1892, 1893, 1897, 1898, 1914, 1948, 1957, 1958, 1991, 1992, 1995, 1996, 1999)

World championships: 3 (1914, 1957, 1995)

Winningest Manager: *Bobby Cox (2,149-1,709, .557)

Boston Beaneaters-Doves-Rustlers-Bees-Braves/Milwaukee Braves/Atlanta Braves Starting Nine

Catcher: Javy Lopez (1992-2003, .287/.337/.502)

First base: Freddie Freeman (2010-present, .293/.379/.504)

Second base: Marcus Giles (2001-06, .285/.361/.448)

Shortstop: Rafael Furcal (2000-05, .284/.348/.409)

Third base: *Eddie Mathews (1952-66, .271/.376/.509)

Left field: *Chipper Jones (1993, 1995-202, .303/.401/.529)

Center field: Andruw Jones (1996-2007, .254/.337/.486)

Right field: *Hank Aaron (1954-74, .305/.374/.555)

Pitcher: *Warren Spahn (1942, 1946-64, 356-229/3.05)

Bottom Line: Boston Beaneaters-Doves-Rustlers-Bees-Braves/Milwaukee Braves/Atlanta Braves

When the Braves left Milwaukee more than a half-century ago, they left an indelible mark on the franchise. An argument can be made that the three greatest players in franchise history played there. They would Hank Aaron, Eddie Mathews and Warren Spahn, of course.

Fortunately, because Chipper Jones played 352 games in left field, we didn’t have to choose between him and Mathews at the hot corner. While Joe Torre had the best numbers behind the plate in the regular season, he never took part in a playoff game. That’s where Javy Lopez had a distinct advantage with 10 homers and a .493 slugging percentage in 60 postseason games.

Some like Glenn Hubbard at second base because of his superior range in the field. We prefer Marcus Giles because of his far more active bat.

What People Say About the Boston Beaneaters-Doves-Rustlers-Bees-Braves/Milwaukee Braves/Atlanta Braves

Chipper Jones celebrating — Chipper Jones played his whole 19-year career with the Braves.

"If you don't like the way the Atlanta Braves are playing, then you don't like baseball." —Former Atlanta Braves manager Chuck Tanner

12. Cleveland Indians: Next Year’s Champions

Bob Feller and Roger Peckinpaugh — Cleveland Indians ace Bob Feller and manager Roger Peckinpaugh talk shop.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 9,477-9,037 (.512)

Playoff appearances: 14

Pennants: 6 (1920, 1948, 1954, 1995, 1997, 2016)

World championships: 2 (1920, 1948)

Winningest manager: *Lou Boudreau (728-649, .529)

Cleveland Indians Starting Nine

Catcher: Victor Martinez (2002-09, .297/.369/.463)

First base: *Jim Thome (1991-2002, 2011, .287/.414/.566)

Second base: *Nap Lojoie (1902-14, .339/.389/.452)

Shortstop: *Lou Boudreau (1938-50, .296/.382/.416)

Third base: Al Rosen (1947-56, .285/.384/.495)

Left field: Albert Belle (1989-96, 1984-86, .295/.369/.580)

Center field: *Tris Speaker (1916-26, .354/.444/.520)

Right field: Joe Jackson (1910-15, .374/.441/.542)

Pitcher: *Bob Feller (1936-41, 1945-56, 266-162/3.25)

Bottom Line: Cleveland Indians

Jim Thome hit 612 home runs in his career.

Earl Averill, Larry Doby, Kenny Lofton and Manny Ramirez would have had better chances in left field, but they seldom, if ever, played there.

Tris Speaker and Joe Jackson (pre-Black Sox version) had vice grips on the other two outfield spots. They rank one-two in batting average and two-one in on-base percentage in club history, respectively.

We chose Victor Martinez over Carlos Santana behind the plate because of better offensive numbers, especially in the postseason.

What People Say About the Cleveland Indians

Victor Martinez points up — Victor Martinez was a five-time All-Star.

"Baseball is known for superstitious players and cursed teams—and at the root of every curse, there’s a story. Boston’s curse was to trade Babe Ruth to the Yankees. Cubs fans claim a billy goat is responsible for their futility. And Cleveland’s curse? The club struggled after its pennant-winning 1954 season, but it was rich with optimism just two years later as an onslaught of new talent promised to lift the club once more to the ranks of baseball’s elite—and by 1959 the club was contending for the pennant again. And then GM Frank Lane traded Rocky Colavito to the Detroit Tigers and cursed everything." —Author Tucker Elliot, "Cleveland Indians IQ: The Ultimate Test of True Fandom"

11. Pittsburgh Pirates: Team of the Past

Bill Mazeroski and Roberto Clemente — Bill Mazeroski, left, and Roberto Clemente, played 17 seasons together with the Pirates.

Seasons: 139 (1882-present)

Record: 10,545-10,405 (.503)

Playoff appearances: 17

Pennants: 9 (1901, 1902, 1903, 1909, 1925, 1927, 1960, 1971, 1979)

World championships: 5 (1909, 1925, 1960, 1971, 1979)

Winningest manager: *Fred Clarke (1,422-969, .595)

Pittsburgh Pirates Starting Nine

Catcher: Tony Pena (1980-86, .286/.327/.411)

First base: *Willie Stargell (1962-82, .282/.360/.529)

Second base: *Bill Mazeroski (1956-72, .260/.299/.367)

Shortstop: *Honus Wagner (1900-17, .328/.394/.468)

Third base: *Pie Traynor (1920-35, 1937, .320/.362/.435)

Left field: Barry Bonds (1986-92, .275/.380/.503)

Center field: Andrew McCutchen (2009-17, .292/.381/.487)

Right field: *Roberto Clemente (1955-72, .317/.359/.475)

Pitcher: Babe Adams (1907, 1909-16, 1918-26, 194-139/2.74)

Bottom Line: Pittsburgh Pirates

Roberto Clemente, making a sensational catch at Wrigley Field in 1958, was one of the best all-around players in baseball history.

This franchise had it all — tradition, legends and championship banners. Only one (guess who) won more World Series in the 1960s-1970s decades.

Then free agency went bonkers, some jamoke owner took over, and a once-proud franchise was reduced to rubble.

What you see here is likely what you’ll get decades from now. No superstar will ever be in the ‘Burgh long enough.

What People Say About the Pittsburgh Pirates

Barry Bonds slides safely under the tag of Chicago Cubs third baseman Wade Rowdon — Barry Bonds played seven seasons with the Pirates.

"Pittsburgh isn't fancy, but it is real. It's a working town and money doesn't come easy. I feel as much a part of this city as the cobblestone streets and the steel mills, people in this town expect an honest day's work, and I've given it to them for a long, long time." —Willie Stargell

10. Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins: Armed and Dangerous

Rod Carew was a lifetime .328 hitter and won seven batting titles in his career.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 8,903-9,603 (.481)

Playoff appearances: 16

Pennants: 6 (1924, 1925, 1933, 1965, 1987, 1991)

World championships: 3 (1924, 1987, 1991)

Winningest manager: Bucky Harris (1,336-1,416, .485)

Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins Starting Nine

Catcher: Joe Mauer (2004-18, .306/.388/.439)

First base: *Rod Carew (1967-78, .334/.393/.448)

Second base: Chuck Knoblauch (1991-97, .304/.391/.416)

Shortstop: *Joe Cronin (1928-34, .304/.387/.455)

Third base: *Harmon Killebrew (1961-1974, .260/.383/.518 )

Left field: *Goose Goslin (1921-30 1933, 1938, .323/.386/.502)

Center field: *Kirby Puckett (1984-95, .318/.360/.477)

Right field: *Sam Rice (1915-33, .323/.375/.429)

Pitcher: *Walter Johnson (1907-27, 417-279/2.17)

Bottom Line: Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins

Seven legit Hall of Famers? Not bad. Harmon Killebrew was eligible at three positions — first base, third base and left field — a nice problem to have here.

We decided on the hot corner, which tipped over the final three dominos. It allowed Rod Carew to play first base, which created a spot for Chuck Knoblauch at second and left a vacancy for Goose Goslin in the outfield.

In the hunt: third baseman Gary Gaetti, first baseman Kent Hrbek, left fielder Heinie Manush and right fielder Tony Oliva.

What People Say About the Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins

Goose Goslin with bat — Goose Goslin hit .323 in 12 seasons with the Washington Senators.

"(Calvin) Griffith is horse spit. They (the Twins) are penny pinchers. They take everything they can get and give nothing in return." —Hall of Famer Rod Carew on former Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins owner Calvin Griffith, who owned the team from 1955 to 1984. Griffith was the last of the family MLB owners whose baseball franchise represented their primary business and money source.

9. New York Highlanders/Yankees 2.0: The Next Best Team Money Can Buy

New York Yankees catcher Yogi Berra won 10 World Series titles.

Seasons: 118 (1903-present)

Record: 10,378-7,840 (.570)

Playoff appearances: 55

World championships: 27 (1923, 1927, 1928, 1932, 1936, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1941, 1943, 1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1956, 1958, 1961, 1962, 1977, 1978, 1996, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2009)

Second-winningest manager: *Joe Torre (1,173-767, .605)

New York Highlanders/Yankees 2.0 Starting Nine

Catcher: *Yogi Berra (1946-63, 1965, .285/.348/.483)

First base: Don Mattingly (1982-95, 1996, .307/.358/.471)

Second base:*Tony Lazzeri (1926-37, .293/.379/.467)

Shortstop: *Phil Rizzuto (1941-42, 1946-56, .273/.351/.355)

Third base: Graig Nettles (1973-83, .253/.329/.433)

Left field: *Rickey Henderson (1985-89, .288/.395/.455)

Center field: *Mickey Mantle (1951-68, .298/.421/.557)

Right field: Tommy Henrich (1937-42, 1946-50, .282/.392/.491)

Pitcher: *Lefty Gomez (1930-42, 189-101/3.34)

Bottom Line: New York Highlanders/Yankees 2.0

Mickey Mantle on the B Team? Yogi Berra? Lefty Gomez? Yeah, we’d take our chances with this group against most others on the list.

Metrics geeks could make a good case for Robinson Cano at second base. We deferred to Tony Lazzeri, the Hall of Famer of "Murderers Row" lore.

Had Rickey Henderson played in Gotham a bit longer and/or with a World Series winner, he would be a first-team selection.

What People Say About the New York Highlanders/Yankees 2.0

New York Yankees centerfielder Rickey Henderson makes flying leap to rob Boston Red Sox Bill Buckner — Rickey Henderson played five seasons with the Yankees and made four AL All-Star teams in that time.

"I'm a lucky guy, and I’m happy to be with the Yankees. And I want to thank everyone for making this night necessary." —Yogi Berra, expressing one his famous Yogi-isms

8. Detroit Tigers: Motown’s Greatest Hits

Al Kaline, running, was an 18-time All-Star.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 9,346-9,191 (.504)

Playoff appearances: 16

Pennants: 11 (1907, 1908, 1909, 1934, 1935, 1940, 1945, 1968, 1984, 2006, 2012)

World championships: 4 (1935, 1945,1968,1984)

Winningest manager: *Sparky Anderson (1,331-1,248, .516)

Detroit Tigers Starting Nine

Catcher: Lance Parrish (1977-86, .263/.317/.469)

First base: *Hank Greenberg (1930-41, 1945-46, .319/.412/.605)

Second base: *Charlie Gehringer (1924-42, .320/.404/.480)

Shortstop: *Alan Trammell (1977-96, .285/.352/.415)

Third base: Miguel Cabrera (2008-19, .315/.394/.543)

Left field: Bobby Veach (1912-23, .311/.370/.442)

Center field: *Ty Cobb (1905-26, .367/.433/.512)

Right field: *Al Kaline (1953-74, .297/.376/.480)

Pitcher: *Hal Newhouser (1939-53, 200-148/2.86)

Bottom Line: Detroit Tigers

Ty Cobb, sliding, scored 2,245 runs in his career.

Should Hal Newhouser be penalized because he starred in the war years? Not enough to move Justin Verlander ahead of him, anyway.

Harry Heilmann hit .390 or better four times, yet he couldn’t beat out Hank Greenberg, whose 1937-1938 seasons rank among the best at any position. So who’s Bobby Veach? DuckDuckGo him, kids.

World Series hero Kirk Gibson would have been a popular pick here, no doubt. Too bad he didn’t play left field. Cabrera did spend two seasons at third base, or just enough to claim the spot.

What People Say About the Detroit Tigers

Detroit Tigers' Miguel Cabrera shouts in celebration — Miguel Cabrera joined the 500 home run club in 2021.

"It wasn't a team of stars. It was a team of guys who played hard every day, grinders. We were blue-collar, like where we were from." —Kirk Gibson, on the 1984 World Series champion Tigers

7. Cincinnati Red Stockings/Redlegs/Reds: The Biggest Red Machine

Bucky Walters — William "Bucky" Walters getting loose in 1939.

Seasons: 139 (1882-present)

Record: 10,599-10,393 (.505)

Playoff appearances: 15

Pennants: 10 (1919, 1939, 1940, 1961, 1970, 1972, 1975, 1976, 1990)

World championships: 5 (1919, 1940, 1975, 1976,1990)

Winningest manager: *Sparky Anderson (863-586, .596)

Cincinnati Red Stockings/Redlegs/Reds Starting Nine

Catcher: *Johnny Bench (1967-83, .267/.342/.476)

First base: Joey Votto (2007-present, .307/.421/.519)

Second base: *Joe Morgan (1972-79, .288/.415/.470)

Shortstop: *Barry Larkin (1986-2004, .295/.371/.444)

Third base: *Tony Perez (1964-76, 1984-86, .283/.346/.474)

Left field: Pete Rose (1963-78, 1984-86, .307/.379/.425)

Center field: *Edd Roush (1916-26, 1931, .331/.377/.462)

Right field: *Frank Robinson (1956-65, .303/.389/.554)

Pitcher: Bucky Walters (1938-48, 160-107/3.30)

Bottom Line: Cincinnati Red Stockings/Redlegs/Reds

Is there a more valuable player than Pete Rose on the all-time franchise list? Don’t bet on it.

He started at least 500 games at each of five positions here. We started with "Charlie Hustle" at his best spot defensively (left field) and was able to keep him there, so the pieces fell nicely into place around him.

The only debate came in center field, where Edd Roush and Vada Pinson had very similar metrics. Roush got the call because of his two batting titles and one World Series title.

What People Say About the Cincinnati Red Stockings/Redlegs/Reds

Cincinnati Reds' Joey Votto slides into home — Joey Votto was NL MVP in 2010.

"The man I marvel at is the one that's in there day after day, and night after night and still puts the figures on the board. I'm talking about Pete Rose, Stan Musial, the real stars. Believe me, especially the way we travel today, flying all night with a game the next night and then the next afternoon, if you can play one-hundred and sixty-two games, you're a man. ... [Pete Rose] is Cincinnati. He's the Reds." —Sparky Anderson

6. Boston Americans/Red Sox: The Killer B’s

Cy Young won 511 games in his career, including 192 with the Boston Americans/Red Sox.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 9,602-8,908 (.519)

Playoff appearances: 24

Pennants: 14 (1903, 1904, 1912, 1915, 1916, 1918, 1946, 1967, 1975, 1986, 2004, 2007, 2013, 2018)

World championships: 9 (1903, 1912, 1915, 1916, 1918, 2004, 2007, 2013, 2018)

Winningest manager: *Joe Cronin (1,071-916, .539)

Boston Americans/Red Sox Starting Nine

Catcher: *Carlton Fisk (1969, 1971-80, .284/.356/.481)

First base: *Jimmie Foxx (1936-42, .320/.429/.605)

Second base: Dustin Pedroia (2006-present, .299/.365/.439)

Shortstop: Nomar Garciaparra (1996-2004, .323/.370/.553)

Third base: *Wade Boggs (1982-92, .338/.428/.462)

Left field: *Ted Williams (1939-42, 1946-60, .344/.482/.634)

Center field: *Tris Speaker (1907-15, .337/.414/.482)

Right field: Mookie Betts (2014-19, .301/.374/.519)

Pitcher: *Cy Young (1901-08, 192-112/2.00)

Bottom Line: Boston Americans/Red Sox

Ted Williams and Joe Cronin — Boston Red Sox star Ted Williams, left, talks with manager Joe Cronin in 1941.

Talk about a tough crowd. Carl Yastrzemski was eligible at first base and left field, yet the 18-time All-Star still couldn’t crack the lineup. David Ortiz and his 483 home runs should have had a spot as well, but he was a man without a position.

Pitchers Roger Clemens and Pedro Martinez also deserved better. But, really, how could we snub the guy who averaged 24 wins and 341 innings per season? And would have the most prestigious award at the position named after him?

Full disclosure: I was sooooo tempted to include Babe Ruth somewhere just to hack off Red Sox and Yankees fans.

What People Say About the Boston Americans/Red Sox

Mookie Betts celebrating with team — Mookie Betts, front center, played six seasons in Boston.

"If he'd just tip his cap once, he could be elected mayor of Boston in five minutes." —Eddie Collins on Ted Williams, who did not have an easy relationship with Red Sox fans, despite being one of the greatest hitters of all time

5. Philadelphia/Kansas City/Oakland Athletics: The Best Team Money Could Sell

Jimmy Foxx, Mickey Cochrane, and Al Simmons — The big guns in the Philadelphia Athletics' lineup in 1929. Left to right: Jimmy Foxx, Mickey Cochrane and Al Simmons.

Seasons: 120 (1901-present)

Record: 9,028-9,452 (.489)

Playoff appearances: 28

Pennants: 15 (1902, 1905, 1910, 1911, 1913, 1914, 1929, 1930, 1931, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1988, 1989, 1990)

World hampionships: 9 (1910, 1911, 1913, 1929, 1930, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1989)

Winningest manager: *Connie Mack (3,582-3,814, .484)

Philadelphia/Kansas City/Oakland Athletics Starting Nine

Catcher: *Mickey Cochrane (1925-33, .321/.412/.490)

First base: *Jimmie Foxx (1925-35, .339/.440/.640)

Second base: *Eddie Collins (1906-14, 1927-30, .337/.423/.437)

Shortstop: Bert Campaneris (1964-81, 1983, .259/.311/.342)

Third base: *Home Run Baker (1908-13, .321/.375/.471)

Left field: *Rickey Henderson (1979-84, 1989-95, 1998, .288/.409/.430)

Center field: *Al Simmons (1924-32, 1940-41, 1944, .356/.398/.584)

Right field: *Reggie Jackson (1967-75, 1987, .262/.355/.496)

Pitcher: *Lefty Grove (1925-33, 1969-84, 195-79/2.88)

Bottom Line: Philadelphia/Kansas City/Oakland Athletics

Rickey Henderson stole a major league-record 1,406 bases in his career.

Elite talent hasn’t been a problem for this franchise over the decades. The dilemma is how to keep it.

These eight Hall of Famers (eight) are more than any franchise on this list, the New York Yankees included. (Yo, Campy, get with the program!) Several all-timers were left out, most notably Eddie Plank, who won more games (284) than any pitcher in franchise history.

We would feel comfortable with this bunch against any opponent in a best-of-seven series.

What People Say About the Philadelphia/Kansas City/Oakland Athletics

Oakland Athletics's center fielder Reggie Jackson gets congratulatory hug — Reggie Jackson, right, and Bert Campaneris won three World Series with the A's in the 1970s.

"If a manager of mine ever said someone was indispensable, I'd fire him." —Former MLB owner Charlie Finley, who owned the A's from 1960 to 1980 and had 18 managers

4. New York/San Francisco Giants: Forever Giants

Seasons: 138 (1883-present)

Record: 11,165-9,687 (.535)

Playoff appearances: 26

Pennants: 23 (1888, 1889, 1904, 1905, 1911, 1912, 1913, 1917, 1921, 1922, 1923, 1924, 1933, 1936, 1937, 1951, 1954, 1962, 1989, 2002, 2010, 2012, 2014)

World championships: 8 (1905, 1921, 1922, 1933, 1954, 2010, 2012, 2014)

Winningest manager: *John McGraw (2,583-1,790, .591)

New York/San Francisco Giants Starting Nine

Catcher: Buster Posey (2009-present, .302/.370/.456)

First base: *Bill Terry (1923-36, 1996, .341/.393/.506)

Second base: *Frankie Frisch (1919-26, .321/.367/.444 )

Shortstop: Art Fletcher (1909-20, .275/.318/.356)

Third base: Matt Williams (1987-96, .264/.312/.498)

Left field: Barry Bonds (1993-2007, .312/.477/.666 )

Center field: *Willie Mays (1951-72, .304/.385/.564)

Right field: *Mel Ott (1926-47, .304/.414/.533)

Pitcher: *Christy Mathewson (1900-16, 372-188/2.12)

Bottom Line: New York/San Francisco Giants

Willie Mays is one of the greatest players in baseball history.

This franchise is on the short list of greatest in pro sports history, so it’s no surprise that its lineup reads like a who’s who in baseball.

How could one go wrong with either Christy Mathewson, Carl Hubbell or Juan Marichal on the mound? And Terry or Willie McCovey at first base? While Travis Jackson might be a popular choice at shortstop, a deeper dive convinced us that Art Fletcher and his 12th-best defensive WAR total deserved the spot even more.

Also strongly considered was Hall of Famer Roger Bresnahan, Mathewson’s longtime batterymate. We opted for Buster Posey because of his better overall numbers and two more World Series titles. Don’t be surprised if he joins Bresnahan in Cooperstown one day.

What People Say About the New York/San Francisco Giants

San Francisco Giants' Buster Posey celebrates homer — Buster Posey, right, has won three World Series rings with the Giants.

"I'm not sure what the hell charisma is, but I get the feeling it's Willie Mays." —Former Cincinnati Reds star Ted Kluszewski

3. Brooklyn Atlantics-Grays-Grooms-Bridegrooms-Superbas-Robins-Dodgers/Los Angeles Dodgers: Dem Hollywood Bums

Brooklyn Dodgers stars in 1952. Left to right: Second baseman Jackie Robinson, first baseman Gil Hodges, catcher Roy Campanella, third baseman Billy Cox and shortstop Pee Wee Reese.

Seasons: 137 (1884-present)

Record: 10,974-9,818 (.528)

Playoff appearances: 33

Pennants: 24 (1889, 1890, 1899, 1900, 1916, 1920, 1941, 1947, 1949, 1952, 1953, 1955, 1956, 1959, 1963, 1965, 1966, 1974, 1977, 1978, 1981, 1988, 2017, 2018)

World championships: six

Winningest manager: *Walter Alston (2,040-1,613 (.558)

Brooklyn Atlantics-Grays-Grooms-Bridegrooms-Superbas-Robins-Dodgers/Los Angeles Dodgers Starting Nine

Catcher: *Mike Piazza (1992-98, .331/.394/.572)

First base: *Gil Hodges (1943, 1947-1961, .274/.360/.488)

Second base: *Jackie Robinson (1947-1956, .311/.409/.474)

Shortstop: *Pee Wee Reese (1940-1942, 1946-1958, .269/.366/.377)

Third base: Ron Cey (1971-82, .264/.359/.445)

Left field: *Zack Wheat (1909-26, .317/.367/.452)

Center field: *Duke Snider (1947-62, .300/.384/.553)

Right field: Dixie Walker (1939-47, .311/.386/.441)

Pitcher: *Sandy Koufax (1955-66, 165-87/2.76)

Bottom Line: Brooklyn Atlantics-Grays-Grooms-Bridegrooms-Superbas-Robins-Dodgers/Los Angeles Dodgers

Mike Piazza wasn’t a better all-around player than Roy Campanella, the heart of the Dodgers in the Fabulous Fifties. But how can you snub the most dominant hitter ever at his position? I better move on before I change my mind again.

I chose Dixie Walker over Babe Herman, whose robust offense was overshadowed by his misadventures on the field. Yes, I’m aware that Walker wanted no part of Jackie Robinson on the team, but this isn’t a list of Best Players Who Walked Their Grandmas Across The Street.

Besides, Cody Bellinger probably will have the job in a year or two, so chill, people.

What People Say About the Brooklyn Atlantics-Grays-Grooms-Bridegrooms-Superbas-Robins-Dodgers/Los Angeles Dodgers

Jackie Robinson signs autographs — Jackie Robinson was a baseball pioneer.

"I bleed Dodger blue and when I die, I'm going to the big Dodger in the sky." —Hall of Fame manager Tommy Lasorda

2. St. Louis Brown Stockings/Browns/Perfectos/Cardinals: Hall of a Team

Seasons: 139 (1882-present)

Record: 10,918-10,063, .520

Playoff appearances: 29

Pennants: 23 (1885, 1886, 1887, 1888, 1926, 1928, 1930, 1931, 1934, 1942, 1943, 1944, 1946, 1964, 1967, 1968, 1982, 1985, 1987, 2004, 2006, 2011, 2013)

World championships: 11 (1926, 1931, 1934, 1942, 1944, 1946, 1964, 1967, 1982, 2006, 2011)

Winningest manager: *Tony LaRussa (1,408-1,182, .544)

St. Louis Brown Stockings/Browns/Perfectos/Cardinals Starting Nine

Catcher: *Ted Simmons (1968-80, .298/.366/.459)

First base: Albert Pujols (2001-11, 1996, .328/.420/.617)

Second base: *Rogers Hornsby (1915-26, 1933, .359/.427/.468)

Shortstop: *Ozzie Smith (1982-96, .272/.350/.344)

Third base: Ken Boyer (1955-77, .267/.322/.401)

Left field: *Joe Medwick (1932-40, 1947-48, .335/.372/.545)

Center field: Jim Edmonds (2000-07, .285/.393/.555)

Right field: *Stan Musial (1941-44, 1946-63, .331/.417/.559)

Pitcher: *Bob Gibson (1959-75, 1969-84, 251-174/2.91)

Bottom Line: St. Louis Brown Stockings/Browns/Perfectos/Cardinals

St. Louis Cardinals shortstop Ozzie Smith flips in the air before a playoff game in 1985.

Arguably, there has been no better franchise in the Senior Circuit than this one. When Albert Pujols gets his plaque, that will make seven Hall of Famers in the lineup. That there was some intense competition for several berths further vouches for its greatness.

Ted Simmons edged out future Hall of Famer Yadier Molina behind the plate (for now), Ken Boyer nosed out borderline Hall of Famer Scott Rolen at the hot corner and Joe Medwick gently pushed aside Hall of Famer Enos Slaughter in left field.

And don’t forget Hall of Fame outfielder Lou Brock, Hall of Fame pitcher Dizzy Dean, Hall of Fame second baseman Red Schoendienst, Hall of Fame first basemen Jim Bottomley and Johnny Mize.

What People Say About the St. Louis Brown Stockings/Browns/Perfectos/Cardinals

St. Louis Cardinals' Albert Pujols waves to cheering fans during his curtain call — Albert Pujols hit 445 home runs for the Cardinals.

"The two most important things in life: good friends and a strong bullpen." —Hall of Fame pitcher Bob Gibson

1. New York Highlanders/Yankees 1.0: Best Team Money Can Buy

Bill Dickey, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio, and Tony Lazzeri — Four New York Yankees sluggers in 1936, from left to right: Bill Dickey, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio and Tony Lazzeri.

Seasons: 118 (1903-2020)

Record: 10,378-7,840 (.570)

Playoff appearances: 55

World championships: 27 (1923, 1927, 1928, 1932, 1936, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1941, 1943, 1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1956, 1958, 1961, 1962, 1977, 1978, 1996, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2009)

Winningest manager: *Joe McCarthy (1,460-867, .627)

New York Highlanders/Yankees 1.0 Starting Nine

Catcher: *Bill Dickey (1928-43, 1946, .313/.382/.486)

First base: *Lou Gehrig (1923-39, .340/.447/.632)

Second base: *Joe Gordon (1938-43, 1946, .271/.358/.467)

Shortstop: *Derek Jeter (1995-2014, .310/.377/.440)

Third base: Alex Rodriguez (2004-13, 2015-16, .273/.378/.523)

Left field: Charlie Keller (1939-43, 1945-49, 1952, .286/.410/.518)

Center field: *Joe DiMaggio (1936-42, 1946-51, .325/.398/.579)

Right field: *Babe Ruth (1920-34, .349/.484/.711)

Pitcher: *Whitey Ford (1950, 1953-67, 1969-84, 236-106/2.75)

Bottom Line: New York Highlanders/Yankees 1.0

Can there be any doubt that this team is top of the list, king of the hill, A-No. 1?

No fewer than seven Hall of Famers are in the lineup, and if Alex Rodriguez hadn’t been such a lying, cheating narcissist, there would be one more.

Charlie Keller was on a path to Cooperstown before a back problem shortened his career.

What People Say About the New York Highlanders/Yankees 1.0

New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter celebrates — Derek Jeter, The Captain, won five World Series with the Yankees.

"If you're going to play at all, you're out to win. Baseball, board games, playing Jeopardy, I hate to lose." —Derek Jeter